At a glance
| James Hardie fiber cement | Vinyl | LP SmartSide | Natural cedar | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Looks like | Painted wood | Painted wood (varies by line) | Painted wood | Real wood |
| Fire | Noncombustible (ASTM E136), Class A | Combustible | Wood-based | Wood-based |
| Finish | Factory ColorPlus or field paint | Color throughout | Prefinished or field paint | Stain or paint |
| Warranty | 30-yr non-prorated board, transferable; 15-yr ColorPlus finish | Varies by line | 50-yr board (prorated after yr 10 under extended warranty); 15-yr ExpertFinish | None standard |
| Upkeep | Low | Lowest | Low to moderate | Highest |
James Hardie fiber cement
Fiber cement is cement, sand and cellulose fiber pressed into boards. James Hardie invented the category and is what we install most.
The products
- HardiePlank lap siding. 5/16 inch thick, 12 foot boards, exposures from 4 to 10¾ inches. Smooth or Select Cedarmill texture, plus a beaded profile.
- HardieShingle. ¼ inch panels with straight or staggered edges, for a cedar shingle look on gables and dormers or a whole house.
- HardiePanel vertical siding. 4 by 8, 9 or 10 foot sheets in smooth, cedarmill, stucco or Sierra 8 textures. With battens, it's the board-and-batten look on so many modern farmhouses.
- HardieTrim and HardieSoffit. Trim in 4/4 and 5/4 thicknesses; vented or solid soffit.
Why we like it here
- HZ5. James Hardie engineers its HZ5 line for freezing temperatures, big seasonal swings, snow and ice, with an upgraded surface for paint adhesion and moisture resistance and a drip edge for water management.
- Fire. Verified noncombustible per ASTM E136, with a Class A flame spread rating.
- ColorPlus. The finish is baked on and cured in the factory, not brushed on in the weather. It's warranted for 15 years.
- Warranty. The boards carry a 30-year non-prorated, transferable substrate warranty.
James Hardie warrants the product, not the installation. Clearances, flashing, fastening and the water-resistive barrier behind the boards are up to the contractor, and that's where siding jobs succeed or fail. We back our installation with our own workmanship warranty.
Vinyl siding
Good vinyl is a long way from the thin, wavy panels of the 1980s.
- Thickness. 0.035 inch is the industry minimum. Better lines run 0.040 to 0.048 inch, and thicker panels are more rigid, look flatter on the wall and carry higher wind ratings.
- Certification. Building code requires vinyl siding certified to ASTM D3679. Certified products are rated for at least 110 mph winds, and most go higher.
- Insulated vinyl. A foam backing bonded to the panel, certified to ASTM D7793 with a minimum R-2.0. It also stiffens the panel and helps it lie flat.
- Upkeep. Color goes all the way through, so it never needs paint. A periodic wash is all it needs.
LP SmartSide engineered wood
Wood strands bonded with resins and treated against fungal decay and termites, then embossed with a cedar texture. It's lighter than fiber cement and comes in long lengths, which means fewer seams.
- Warranty. Standard SmartSide carries a 5/50-year limited warranty. Prefinished ExpertFinish adds a 15-year finish warranty. Under LP's extended warranty, which requires an LP certified installer, the board is covered for 50 years: labor and material for the first 10, then prorated material only.
Natural cedar
Nothing else looks quite like real cedar, and on many older North Shore homes it's the original material. It also asks the most of you.
- Finish. The Western Red Cedar Lumber Association recommends a primer plus two coats of acrylic latex solid-color stain as the most durable finish. Semi-transparent oil stains show more grain and are easier to refinish.
- Refinishing. There's no fixed schedule. Recoat when the old coating has worn thin. South and west walls go first.
- Installation. Cedar must be able to dry. We install it over a ventilated rainscreen where the wall allows, and finish it at or below 20% moisture content.
Choosing for your house
- Historic and older homes: cedar or fiber cement in a matching profile and exposure, with trim details kept or replicated.
- Postwar ranches and colonials: fiber cement or quality vinyl, often with new trim and soffit to sharpen the whole exterior.
- Modern farmhouses: fiber cement panels and battens, often in ColorPlus.
- Mixed materials: HardieShingle in the gables over lap siding, or stone and siding together.
Every siding job also includes the parts you don't see: house wrap, flashing at windows and doors, and proper clearance from roofs and grade.



