Not sure whether you have a claim? Take the one-minute self-check further down this page.
How a roof claim works
Homeowners policies cover sudden, accidental damage, such as hail bruising, wind-torn shingles or a tree on the roof. They don't cover wear and tear: age, weathering, or a roof that was installed poorly. After you report damage, the insurer sends an adjuster, writes an estimate, and pays according to your policy.
Two parts of the policy decide most of the outcome:
- Your deductible. Many Illinois policies have a separate wind and hail deductible, sometimes a percentage of the home's insured value rather than a flat amount. On a $600,000 home, a 1% deductible is $6,000.
- How the roof is valued. Replacement cost pays to replace the roof, usually in two payments, with the held-back depreciation released after the work is done. Actual cash value subtracts depreciation for age, and some policies put older roofs on a depreciation schedule, which can leave a large gap.
Avoiding a denial: materials
| Watch for | Why it matters | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Roof age and condition | The older the roof, the easier it is to call damage wear | Keep the install date, contract and invoices; replace a roof near the end of its life before a storm decides for you |
| Impact rating | Standard shingles bruise in hail that a Class 4 (UL 2218) shingle can shrug off; some insurers also discount Class 4 roofs | Consider Class 4 shingles such as GAF Timberline UHDZ or Owens Corning Duration FLEX and STORM. See Class 4 roofs |
| Cosmetic-damage exclusions | Some policies won't pay for dents that don't let water in, most often on metal roofs, gutters and trim | Read the policy before choosing metal; ask your agent what "cosmetic" means in your policy |
| Discontinued or hard-to-match shingles | Partial repairs that don't match can lead to disputes over how much of the roof to replace | Keep the product name and color on file so a match can be checked quickly |
| Mixed or off-brand components | A roof built from mismatched parts may not qualify for the manufacturer's system warranty, and gives the insurer room to call problems workmanship | Use one manufacturer's matched system and register the warranty |
Avoiding a denial: installation
| Watch for | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Improper nailing | High or under-driven nails cause blow-offs that an adjuster may call an installation defect rather than wind damage |
| Overlays and multiple layers | Extra layers raise tear-off and code costs. Without ordinance or law coverage, the code-upgrade portion may not be paid |
| Missing ice barrier, drip edge or flashing | Leaks traced to missing components are workmanship, not storm damage |
| Poor attic ventilation | Heat and moisture damage from below looks like aging, not hail |
| No permit | Raises questions about whether the roof met code in the first place |
| Unlicensed or out-of-state installers | Little documentation, no local accountability, and work that's harder to defend later |
Our guide to roof installation mistakes explains each of these in detail.
Avoiding a denial: care and maintenance
Insurers expect you to maintain the roof and to limit damage once it happens. Long-standing problems are the easiest claims to deny.
- Get a roof check every year or two, and after any major storm. Keep the photos and the report.
- Take "before" photos of every side of the roof and the gutters each spring. If a storm hits, you can show the condition before it.
- Fix small problems quickly: a lifted shingle, a cracked pipe boot or loose flashing. A small leak left for a season turns into rot an adjuster will call neglect.
- Keep gutters clean so water and ice don't back up under the shingles.
- Trim overhanging branches that scrape the roof or drop debris.
- Keep a home file: roof contract, product names, warranty registration, permit, inspection reports, repair receipts and photos.
Preparing for a claim
Before storm season
- Read your policy declarations page. Know your wind and hail deductible, whether the roof is covered at replacement cost or actual cash value, and whether you have ordinance or law coverage.
- Take baseline photos of the roof, gutters, siding and the AC unit.
- Choose a licensed roofer now, not after the storm when door-knockers arrive. Check the license at idfpr.illinois.gov.
After a storm
- Confirm the storm. Note the date and time. National Weather Service storm reports and local news show where hail fell and how large it was.
- Look from the ground, not the roof. Check gutters, downspouts, window screens, siding, the AC unit, mailboxes and car hoods for dents. Damaged soft metal is strong evidence of hail.
- Take date-stamped photos of everything, including interior stains.
- Prevent more damage. Tarp or protect leaking areas and keep the receipts. Policies require it, and the cost is usually part of the claim.
- Get a roofer's inspection with photos of each slope and an honest opinion on whether it's worth filing, especially if the damage may be close to your deductible.
- Report promptly to your insurer and write down the claim number.
Managing the claim
- Keep a claim log. Every call and email: date, name, what was said. Ask for important answers in writing.
- Be there for the adjuster's inspection, and have your roofer there too, so the damage your roofer documented is seen on the roof.
- Get the adjuster's estimate in writing and compare it line by line with your roofer's scope: tear-off, underlayment, ice barrier, drip edge, flashing, vents, ridge, gutters and code items.
- Ask for missed items to be reviewed. If items are missing or underpriced, send your roofer's photos and written scope to the adjuster and ask for a re-inspection. Your roofer can document the damage, but in Illinois a contractor can't negotiate the claim for you.
- Understand the payments. The first check is usually the actual cash value. If your mortgage company is named on the check, it may need to endorse it. The held-back depreciation is released after the work is finished and documented, and policies set a deadline for that.
- Watch the deadlines in your policy for completing repairs and submitting final invoices.
- If you disagree, ask for the reasons in writing, provide more evidence, use your policy's appraisal clause for disputes over the amount, or contact the Illinois Department of Insurance. A licensed public adjuster can negotiate for you, for a fee.
Your rights in Illinois
- A roofer must be licensed by IDFPR, and the license number (starting with 104) must be on the contract.
- A contractor can't file or represent you on an insurance claim. Licensed public adjusters can.
- A contractor can't pay or rebate your deductible.
- After a catastrophe such as a hailstorm or windstorm that damages more than one home, you can cancel a roofing contract within five business days after your insurer tells you all or part of the claim isn't covered.
- Never pay in full up front, and get lien waivers from suppliers and subcontractors before the final payment.
How Etruscan helps
We inspect the whole roof and the soft metals around it, photograph every slope by drone, measure the roof with aerial reports (GAF and EagleView, the kind adjusters use), and give you an honest written assessment, including when we think a claim isn't worth filing. If you file, we can meet the adjuster at your home so the damage is seen, and provide the photos and scope you need to ask for a review of missed items. When the work is approved, we build to code and manufacturer spec, pull the permit, register the warranty, and give you the paperwork for your home file, including the documentation insurers ask for on Class 4 roofs.




