At a glance
Weights are per "square," the roofer's unit for 100 square feet of roof. Service lives are industry guidelines that assume normal maintenance, not promises.
| Material | Look | Weight per square | Hail rating | Typical service life | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Architectural asphalt shingle | Dimensional, shadowed | 250–300 lb | Class 4 on impact lines | About 30 years | Most homes; best value |
| Synthetic slate or shake (Brava, DaVinci) | Slate or cedar | About 270–340 lb (DaVinci Multi-Width) | Class 4 | 50-year or lifetime limited warranty | Slate or shake look without the weight |
| Natural slate | Real stone | 650–750 lb or more | Not rated; varies by quarry | 60–150+ years (by grade) | Historic and estate homes |
| Cedar shake and shingle | Natural wood, weathers silver | Light | Not rated | About 25 years with care | Cottage, Shingle and Tudor styles |
| Copper and standing-seam metal | Metal panels, patina | Light | Varies | 70+ years (copper) | Bays, dormers, porches, accents |
Not sure which look suits your house? Try the Roof Makeover Studio: upload a photo and preview slate, shake, shingle and copper on your own roof.
Asphalt shingles
Asphalt shingles cover most Chicagoland roofs, and the category is wider than people expect. The real differences between a cheap roof and a great one are the shingle's construction, its ratings and the system installed under it.
3-tab shingles
A single flat layer, usually 12 by 36 inches, with two cutouts that make three "tabs." They weigh about 200 to 250 pounds per square and are typically designed for winds around 60 mph. InterNACHI's guideline service life is about 20 years. We rarely recommend 3-tab on a home you plan to keep, and most manufacturers have moved their focus to laminated shingles.
Architectural (laminated or dimensional) shingles
Two or more layers bonded together, with the top layer cut into shapes that cast shadows and read as depth from the street. They're larger (about 13 by 39 inches), heavier (250 to 300 pounds per square) and much more wind resistant, typically 110 to 130 mph under the manufacturer's warranty when installed to spec. This is the right choice for most homes we roof.
Designer and luxury shingles
Heavier, multi-layer shingles cut to imitate slate or hand-split shake. They can approach the look of a premium material at a fraction of the weight and cost. Lineups change often; Owens Corning discontinued Berkshire in 2025, for example, so we confirm availability with our suppliers before we quote a designer line.
The shingle lines we install most
We install both GAF and Owens Corning and recommend whichever fits your home. The lines we feature (ratings are the manufacturers'):
- GAF Timberline UHDZ. GAF's most dimensional Timberline, rated UL 2218 Class 4 with an UltraMat core and Class 4 ridge caps to match.
- GAF Timberline HDZ. GAF's #1-selling shingle, rated Class 3, with LayerLock technology that qualifies for GAF's WindProven wind coverage when installed as a full system.
- Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration. Bold color contrast, a 130 mph wind warranty and SureNail Technology in the nailing zone. One of our most-requested shingles.
- Owens Corning Duration FLEX and STORM. Duration styling with Class 4 impact construction. FLEX uses SBS polymer-modified asphalt that stays flexible in the cold.
Full comparison and warranties: GAF and Owens Corning shingle systems. Insurance credits for Class 4 roofs: Class 4 roofs and insurance savings.
What the ratings on the package mean
Fire: UL 790 / ASTM E108
Class A is the highest fire classification, and the asphalt shingle standard (ASTM D3462) requires it. Every shingle we install is Class A. With synthetics and cedar, the fire class depends on the product and the underlayment, so we spec the assembly to reach Class A wherever it's offered.
Impact (hail): UL 2218
Steel balls are dropped on a sample of new roofing. To pass a class, the sample must survive two hits in the same spot at six locations without cracking.
| UL 2218 class | Steel ball | Impact energy |
|---|---|---|
| Class 1 | 1¼ in. | 3.53 ft-lb |
| Class 2 | 1½ in. | 7.35 ft-lb |
| Class 3 | 1¾ in. | 13.56 ft-lb |
| Class 4 | 2 in. | 23.71 ft-lb |
Class 4 is the top rating. Several Illinois insurers, including State Farm, offer a credit for qualifying impact-resistant roofs; amounts vary and aren't guaranteed, so ask your agent. See Class 4 roofs and insurance savings for sample math. Note that synthetic slate warranties often exclude hail damage even on Class 4 products. The rating describes how the product tested, not what the warranty covers.
Wind: ASTM D3161 and ASTM D7158
Two different lab tests:
| Test | Class | Wind speed |
|---|---|---|
| ASTM D3161 (fan-blown) | Class A / D / F | 60 / 90 / 110 mph |
| ASTM D7158 (uplift) | Class D / G / H | 115 / 150 / 190 mph |
The wind speed on a warranty is separate from the test class, and it usually depends on installation details: nail count, starter strips at the edges and approved hip and ridge. That's why we install to the manufacturer's high-wind spec on every roof.
Algae resistance
The black streaks on north-facing roofs are algae (Gloeocapsa magma), not dirt. Algae-resistant shingles use copper-lined granules that slowly release copper to keep it from taking hold. Owens Corning calls this StreakGuard; its algae warranty runs 10 to 25 years depending on the line.
Synthetic slate and shake: Brava and DaVinci
Composite roofing is molded from polymers to look like slate or cedar. It weighs a fraction of natural slate, so it usually goes on existing framing, and it carries a Class 4 impact rating. It's the material we suggest most often for homeowners who love the look of slate but whose framing, budget or timeline doesn't suit the real thing.
Brava Roof Tile
Made in Washington, Iowa, since 2008. Brava molds its tiles from recycled materials and offers slate (including the hand-hewn-look Old World Slate), cedar shake in 5, 7 and 12 inch widths, Spanish barrel and flat tile.
- Impact: UL 2218 Class 4 across the slate, shake, barrel and flat tile lines, confirmed in an independent evaluation report (QAI CERUS-1014).
- Fire: Class A or Class C depending on the product version and approved underlayment. We specify a Class A assembly.
- Wind: Brava rates its tiles up to 188 mph with ring-shank nails and 211 mph with a high-wind screw installation.
- Weight: Brava says up to 65% lighter than traditional materials, and Old World Slate can go over most existing decks without added support.
- Warranty: marketed as a limited "lifetime" 50-year warranty, transferable once. Read the fine print: replacement and labor (capped per square) are covered for the first 10 years, then the remedy becomes a prorated refund. Hail over 1½ inches and algae are excluded.
DaVinci Roofscapes
A Westlake Royal Building Products brand, made in Kansas. Slate lines include Province, Multi-Width, Single-Width and Inspire; shake lines include Select Shake and Multi-Width Shake.
- Material: 100% virgin resins with UV and thermal stabilizers and a fire retardant. DaVinci's spec says recycled materials are not acceptable. That's the clearest difference from Brava.
- Ratings: Class A fire and Class 4 impact across the composite line. DaVinci certifies 110 mph straight-line winds.
- Weight: Multi-Width Slate installs at about 273 to 342 pounds per square depending on exposure.
- Warranty: Lifetime Limited Material Warranty on homes, prorated after year 10. Hail is excluded, and standard wind coverage is 90 mph with an optional upgrade.
Brava or DaVinci?
Both are excellent, and we install both. DaVinci has the longer track record and a virgin-resin formula with a wide architect-favored palette. Brava has deep, hand-hewn textures, very strong wind ratings and a recycled-material story. We bring samples of both to your home and look at them against your brick, stone and trim. Color is usually what decides it.
Natural slate
Slate is stone, split by hand into roofing tiles. A good slate roof can outlast the house. It's also the most demanding roof to install and repair, which is why so many North Shore slate roofs are failing at the flashings and fasteners long before the stone itself wears out.
Grades and quarries
ASTM C406 grades roofing slate S1, S2 or S3 by strength, water absorption and how deeply the surface softens over time.
| Grade | Expected service life |
|---|---|
| S1 | 75 years and up; some quarries 200+ years |
| S2 | 40–75 years |
| S3 | 20–40 years |
Quarry matters as much as grade. North American slate comes mainly from Vermont and New York, Pennsylvania and Buckingham County, Virginia. Imported slate can be good, but durability varies widely, so we buy from sources with a track record and match existing roofs by quarry wherever we can.
Weight and structure
Natural slate weighs roughly 650 to 750 pounds per square, and heavier, thicker slate weighs more, versus about 250 to 300 for architectural shingles. A home that didn't start with slate usually needs an engineering review before switching to it. A home built for slate can almost always be re-slated.
How we install and repair slate
- Copper flashings, typically 16 ounce and occasionally 20 ounce, because they last as long as the stone.
- Copper slating nails sized to twice the slate thickness plus an inch, and a standard 3 inch headlap.
- Matching metals when reusing flashing, to avoid galvanic corrosion.
- Repairs with matching or salvaged slate, set with copper hooks or nails, never roofing cement.
Many slate roofs need repair, not replacement. We'll tell you which yours is.
Cedar shake and shingle
Cedar gives a roof warmth and texture and weathers to a silver gray. It suits Shingle-style, Tudor and cottage homes, and it's common across the older North Shore.
- Shingles vs. shakes. Shingles are sawn smooth and tapered; shakes are split or sawn thicker with a rougher face.
- Grades. Look for the Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau's Certi-label. No. 1 Blue Label shingles are premium, 100% heartwood, clear and edge grain. No. 2 Red Label allows some flat grain and sapwood. No. 3 is utility grade.
- Treated cedar. Certi-Last is pressure-treated with preservative for damp locations. Certi-Guard is pressure-treated with fire retardant and can be part of a Class A, B or C roof assembly. Some villages require fire-retardant shakes.
- Slope. Shakes need at least a 4:12 pitch and shingles at least 3:12.
- Care. Keep branches trimmed and gutters clean, keep vents clear and add zinc or copper ridge strips to discourage moss. The Bureau doesn't recommend power washing.
With good care, cedar lasts about 25 years or more. Where cedar maintenance isn't realistic, a synthetic shake from Brava or DaVinci is the alternative.
Copper and standing-seam metal
Copper is the material we reach for on bay windows, dormers, turrets, porch roofs, cupolas and conductor heads, and sometimes for a whole roof.
- Weight classes. Copper is specified by ounces per square foot: 16 oz (0.0216 in.), 20 oz (0.0270 in.) and 24 oz (0.0323 in.).
- Patina. New copper is bright salmon pink, then turns russet and chocolate brown, and eventually blue-green or gray-green. In suburban air the green typically takes a decade or more. Flat surfaces patina fastest and vertical ones slowest.
- Details that matter. Copper runs hotter than steel, so the underlayment has to be rated for it, and a slip sheet goes between copper and asphalt felt.
- Service life. InterNACHI's guideline is 70 years or more for copper and 40 to 80 for metal roofing in general.
Standing-seam steel and aluminum in black, bronze and other factory finishes suit modern homes and low-slope porch roofs. We'll recommend the gauge and finish for your roof when we inspect it.
The system under the roof
What you see is maybe half of a good roof. The rest is the system underneath, and it's where most leaks start.
- Ice and water barrier. Chicagoland gets ice dams, so code requires a self-adhering ice barrier from the eave to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall, measured horizontally. On a 6/12 roof with a 12 inch overhang, that's about 47 inches up the slope, more than one roll. We also run it in valleys and around chimneys and skylights.
- Underlayment. A synthetic or felt layer over the rest of the deck as a second line of defense.
- Starter strips and hip and ridge. Required for full wind ratings, and part of every manufacturer system warranty.
- Ventilation. Balanced intake at the soffits and exhaust at the ridge, sized to the attic. Poor ventilation cooks shingles from below and feeds ice dams. Air sealing and insulation matter just as much; see attic insulation.
- Flashing and drip edge. New metal flashing at walls, chimneys and skylights, and drip edge at the eaves and rakes.
Warranties, decoded
Every warranty has two halves: the material (the manufacturer covers defects in the product) and the workmanship (someone covers how it was installed).
- GAF. System Plus, Silver Pledge and Golden Pledge add up to 50 years of non-prorated material coverage and, on the top tiers, workmanship coverage. Details: GAF warranties.
- Shingle alone. Owens Corning's Limited Lifetime warranty on Oakridge and Duration includes a 10-year non-prorated period ("TRU PROtection").
- System Protection and Preferred Protection. Install a full Owens Corning system, and these extend non-prorated material coverage to 50 years on a single-family home. Preferred Protection adds 10 years of workmanship coverage.
- Platinum Protection. Offered only by Platinum Preferred Contractors, fewer than 1% of Owens Corning contractors. It adds limited lifetime workmanship coverage backed by Owens Corning itself, not just the contractor.
- Synthetics. Brava and DaVinci warranties are long, but both become prorated refunds after year 10 and both exclude hail. We'll show you the documents.
We register every eligible warranty for you and give you copies at the final walkthrough.




