At a glance
| Gutter | Drains up to (roof area) | Look | Common materials |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 in. K-style | About 5,520 sq ft | Crown-molding profile | Aluminum, copper, steel |
| 6 in. K-style | About 7,960 sq ft | Crown-molding profile | Aluminum, copper, steel |
| 5 in. half-round | About 2,500 sq ft | Rounded, traditional | Copper, aluminum |
| 6 in. half-round | About 3,840 sq ft | Rounded, traditional | Copper, aluminum |
Capacities are for a single run at moderate roof pitch. K-style carries much more water than a half-round of the same width, which is why half-round systems often need more downspouts.
K-style or half-round?
K-style gutters have a flat back and a decorative front that echoes crown molding. They carry the most water for their size and suit most homes built after the 1940s.
Half-round gutters are the traditional profile on older homes: Victorian, Tudor, Georgian and Prairie-era houses all over Evanston, Wilmette, Winnetka and Lake Forest. They hold less water for their width, so we size them up or add downspouts to compensate. In copper, they're one of the most beautiful details a house can have.
Sizing gutters and downspouts
Gutter size should come from the roof, not from habit. We look at:
- Roof area draining into each run, not the whole house. Big, steep roof planes dump a lot of water into one gutter.
- Pitch. Steep roofs shed water faster. A 12/12 roof needs about 30% more capacity than a low-slope roof of the same footprint.
- Downspout spacing. The University of Illinois rule of thumb: a 5 inch gutter works if downspouts are less than 30 feet apart, the pitch is 9/12 or less and the roof area is under 30 times the gutter length. Otherwise, go to 6 inch.
- Downspout size. Allow about 1 square inch of downspout per 100 square feet of roof. A 2x3 downspout handles about 600 square feet; a 3x4 handles about 1,200, more than double.
- Slope and outlets. Gutters should fall about ¼ inch per 10 feet, and runs of 60 feet or more get at least two outlets.
For complex roofs we use the SMACNA method, which sizes gutters from local rainfall intensity.
Hand-mitered corners: the detail we're proudest of
Corners are where gutters most often fail and where shortcuts show. Two runs of water meet there, the gutter changes direction, and every joint has to stay sealed through decades of summer heat and winter ice.
Most installers use a preformed corner: a factory-made "box miter" or "strip miter" piece bought from the supply house and attached to the ends of two runs. It's fast. But it adds joints, the piece is often lighter-gauge aluminum than the gutter itself, and the color and profile rarely match exactly.
We hand-miter our corners. Our installers cut each run at a precise angle on site, from the same coil as the rest of the gutter, then fold, overlap, rivet and seal the joint so the gutter turns the corner as one continuous piece.
| Hand-mitered corner (Etruscan) | Preformed box or strip miter | |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Unbroken profile that turns the corner like crown molding | A visible add-on piece, with seams on both sides |
| Material and color | Same coil, gauge and finish as the gutter | Often thinner stock; color can drift from the gutter over time |
| Joints to seal | One joint, folded and overlapped | Two joints, plus the corner piece itself |
| Water flow | Smooth inside face; water turns the corner without catching | Lips and edges inside the corner can catch debris and slow water where flow is heaviest |
| Fit | Cut to the exact angle of the house, including bay windows and odd angles | Fixed angles; the house has to fit the part |
A preformed corner can be installed well, and a hand miter can be sloppy, because the result always comes down to the installer. We take the extra time on every corner because it shows from the street and it keeps water where it belongs. Look at the corners of your gutters: you'll see the difference.
Materials
Seamless aluminum
The workhorse. We form seamless gutters on site from heavy coil (0.032 inch where we can), so there are no joints along the run to leak, and we hand-miter the corners (see above). Aluminum doesn't rust, comes in dozens of factory colors and lasts 20 to 40+ years.
Copper
Copper gutters are specified by weight: 16 oz copper is 0.0216 inch thick and 20 oz is 0.0270 inch, about 25% thicker. We use 16 oz for most residential work and 20 oz for wide or heavy-duty runs. Copper starts bright, weathers to brown and eventually to green, and lasts 50+ years. Seams are soldered, not caulked.
Galvanized steel
Strong, but it needs paint and eventually rusts. Typical service life is about 20 years.
Built for Chicago winters
Ice is the real test of a gutter. What we do differently:
- Hanger spacing. Manufacturers suggest a hanger every 24 inches, or every 18 inches in heavy snow and ice. The University of Illinois recommends 16 to 24 inches where snow and ice last. We use the tight end.
- Fascia first. Hangers are only as strong as the wood behind them, so we check and replace soft fascia before hanging new gutters.
- Correct pitch. Gutters that hold standing water freeze solid.
- Ice dams start at the roof. If your gutters fill with ice every winter, the cause is usually heat escaping into the attic. See attic insulation.
Gutter guards: an honest look
Guards reduce cleaning; none eliminate it.
| Type | Good at | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Stainless micro-mesh | Blocks nearly all debris; handles snow and heavy rain | Costs more; must be supported so it doesn't sag; fine sludge still collects |
| Screen | Durable, inexpensive | Pine needles and shingle grit get through |
| Reverse-curve (surface tension) | Sheds leaves | Bulky and visible; overshoots in heavy rain; collects snow and ice |
| Brush | Pine needles, twigs | Mats in wet or snowy climates; needs regular cleaning |
| Foam insert | Easy to install | Degrades in a few seasons; holds moisture |
We install supported stainless micro-mesh, fastened so it doesn't slide under the first course of shingles, which can void some shingle warranties.
Downspouts and drainage
A gutter is only as good as where it puts the water. We place downspouts to keep water off walks and driveways where it can freeze, extend them away from the foundation and can tie into existing underground drains. Where downspouts are a feature, such as a front elevation or a historic home, copper or round downspouts and conductor heads can turn a necessity into a detail.




